Talk to a rare coin expert and know what to do next.
Whether you want an appraisal, need help with an inherited collection or would prefer a secure private appointment, tell us what you have and we’ll guide you on the most sensible next step.
Private appointment or Long Island storefront?
Some clients want a private meeting. Others prefer to come to our Long Island location. Both options are designed to make discussing valuable coins and collections comfortable, secure and straightforward.
Prefer a Private Appointment?
Many clients prefer a more private, secure setting when discussing valuable coins, bullion or inherited collections. We completely understand why.
Rare Date Coins regularly arranges confidential appointments in secure, neutral locations.
Whether you’re handling a family inheritance, managing an estate or simply don’t feel comfortable carrying valuables into a public setting, we’ll help arrange an appointment that feels safe, discreet and appropriate.
Arrange a Private AppointmentVisit Our Long Island Storefront
Goldfellas is the Long Island retail storefront created in partnership with Rare Date Coins, offering secure appraisals for coins, bullion and collectibles.
Goldfellas Long Island90 Broadhollow Rd
Melville, Long Island, NY 11747
Call: (718) 905-9186 Visit the Goldfellas Page
A clear process from the first conversation.
You don’t need to know what your coins are worth before you contact us. Start with what you have and we’ll guide you from there.
Share your coins or collection details
Send us photos, an inventory list or a brief description of what you have through our contact form or WhatsApp.
Receive an initial review
We’ll assess whether your coins are primarily bullion, collectible rarities or items that may benefit from professional grading and explain the most sensible next steps.
Arrange your appraisal or consultation
From secure in-person appointments to remote evaluations and auction guidance, we’ll help you choose the right route for your collection and priorities.
Your collection should be handled as carefully as you would handle it yourself.
We understand that coin collections, bullion and inherited valuables often carry both significant financial value and personal importance.
That’s why every interaction with Rare Date Coins is handled with professionalism, discretion and transparency from the beginning.
We work with collectors, families and estate professionals across the United States.
Although our storefront is based in Long Island, Rare Date Coins regularly travels for major coin shows, estate appointments and private consultations.
Whether you’re based in New York, Florida, California, Pennsylvania or elsewhere, our process is designed to make expert coin appraisals and sales guidance straightforward, secure and accessible.
Explore Our LocationsFind out what your coins are really worth.
Tell us what you have and we’ll help you understand the right next step, whether that means an appraisal, grading, a private meeting or simply getting a clearer picture of your collection.